View Full Version : Young Drivers: Sound Off About McGuinty's New Laws Restricting Young Drivers

18-11-2008, 08:01 PM
New Law Restricts Young Drivers

It all started in Muskoka, at the beginning of the summer. On July 3, 2008 Tyler Mulcahy, age 20, his girlfriend Nastasia Inez Elzinga, 19, and buddies Kourosh Totonchian, 19, and Cory Mintz, 20, were eating and drinking at the Water's Edge restaurant at the Lake Joseph Club in Port Carling. After consuming 31 beverages in three hours, the friends left in Mulcahy's Audi, which he was driving when he lost control and crashed in the Joseph River. Only Elzinga survived.

Right after that tragic event, Tim Mulcahy spent his own money on a very public crusade to introduce tough new teen drinking and driving laws. Today he succeeded.

In a phone conversation with Dalton McGuinty, Tim Mulcahy remarked that with these new laws, Ontario will have the safest roads in the world. But if you are between the ages of 16 and 21, they will also be the most restrictive.

The new laws would have police enforce:

A total ban on alcohol consumption

A ban on more than one teenage passenger

Zero tolerance for speeders Ė one ticket and they're off the road.

CSR expert ( storyteller Billie Mintz (, an innovator in new media formats, is currently in production on a new project that investigates the distribution of the responsible drinking message. He wants to hear what you think about McGuinty's proposed new laws?

The Message in a Bottle ( is a 12 part web video series which analyzes the responsibility everyone shares regarding the advertising, sales, purchase and consumption of alcohol.

The world is changing; Ontario is becoming a safer place, but are we sacrificing freedom for safety?

Itís human nature to want to place blame, and pinpoint a problem, but who is to blame for each summerís tragic drinking and driving deaths?

Sound off here and your comments could be included in The Message in a Bottle ( web video series. Do you have a video camera? Include links to your video comments and we might license your footage. Please participate.

How old are you? Where do you live? What do you think of McGuinty's proposed tough new legislation restricting young drivers?

19-11-2008, 09:13 AM
I hope it does some good and reduces the number of fatalities on our roads but I have my doubts.
Some of the provisions of this legislation seem like they were crafted to give the appearance of a government that is hard at work, making it's citizens safer and happier, rather than producing any real results.
It reminds me of the cell phone in car ban from a little while back. The cell phone ban in cars does nothing to protect drivers from people who eat while driving, put on makeup while driving, read while driving, etc.

This new legislation is for young people who are concerned about following laws. What about those who don't care about the law? I like the speeding ban from driving. That's actually productive. Someone speeds, they get taken off the road. What about the other offences? Driving with more than one teen in the car or driving with any alcohol in the blood. Will those be enforced with driving bans too? If so, then maybe this law will have some teeth to it.

There is definitely some freedom being sacrificed for safety here. Dictating who you can carry as passengers is an infringement.

19-11-2008, 02:24 PM
In my opinion it compromises my rights and freedoms as a Canadian citizen.

Shinto-Canadian Bloke
20-04-2009, 05:44 PM
driving is a priviledge not a right

13-10-2009, 11:28 PM
I don't believe that a sudden change in laws will make young drivers more cautious or understanding. It seems more reasonable to assume that proper upbringing with good ethics and morals leads to overall better people! As for any government, once they see an opportunity to make money they suddenly ignore the absurdity revolving around some laws.